Initially, 'Thick as Thieves' presents itself as a captivating first-person stealth experience, drawing parallels to beloved titles within the immersive sim genre. The game successfully integrates elements like lean mechanics and distinct, hand-drawn map designs, hinting at a nostalgic return to classic stealth gameplay. The blend of technological and magical themes, highlighted by unique guard behaviors such as ghostly patrols, contributes to an intriguing world. However, as the experience progresses, certain design decisions, particularly the stringent time constraints, begin to undermine the potential for a truly engaging single-player journey, ultimately leading to a sense of missed opportunity.
My early encounters with 'Thick as Thieves' were largely positive, as I navigated its environments with a growing appreciation for its intricate design. The game's setting, featuring a police station and Elway Manor, offered multi-layered buildings with diverse entry points, encouraging strategic exploration and a sense of mastery with each return. The guards' keen awareness of environmental changes, like extinguished lights or open doors, added a layer of realism to the stealth mechanics. The inclusion of peculiar 'ghost guards' whose patrols extended beyond physical boundaries, yet maintained an audible presence, was a clever touch that kept players on their toes, even in seemingly safe areas.
The game's developers, Otherside, have openly discussed a pivot in 'Thick as Thieves' development, shifting its focus from a PvPvE model to one that supports both single-player and co-operative modes. This transition, while aiming to broaden its appeal, appears to have inadvertently limited the game's scope, evidenced by the restricted number of maps and the inability to customize key bindings. Despite these limitations, the initial thrill of discovering new areas and experimenting with abilities like the pickpocket and insult fairies provided moments of genuine enjoyment, evoking the satisfaction of mastering a complex environment, much like revisiting familiar locations in titles such as 'Hitman'.
However, the imposition of strict time limits became a significant point of contention. Missions typically allot 45 minutes, sometimes less, to complete objectives before a magical escape door manifests. Following this, players are given a mere eight minutes to locate and reach the randomly appearing exit. This mechanic, while perhaps intended to inject urgency and promote a faster-paced stealth experience for co-op play, proved counterproductive for the single-player mode. The pressure of the ticking clock often discouraged thorough exploration and creative problem-solving, instead fostering a rushed approach to objectives. This was particularly frustrating when the timer for escape would activate prematurely, such as after collecting the first of multiple objective items, leading to frantic searches for remaining items and ultimately, missed opportunities for strategic play.
A particularly frustrating incident involved an escape door appearing in an inaccessible location, rendering the mission unwinnable. Such occurrences, whether due to design oversight or technical glitches, highlight the flaws in the time-limit system. For a game that started with such promise, blending classic stealth elements with unique magical twists, these arbitrary constraints diminish the overall single-player experience. While priced affordably, the current state of 'Thick as Thieves' might leave solo players yearning for a more forgiving, expansive, and less hurried stealth adventure that truly lives up to its early immersive sim aspirations.
